One of my favorite books, East of Eden by John Steinbeck, delivers unforgettable storytelling and profound insights into human nature. A line that resonates deeply with me is:
“And now that you don’t have to be perfect, you can be good.”
This single line captures a powerful truth, but like any great story, East of Eden provides much more than just a memorable quote. Its themes and conflicts come alive through the way its parts connect to create a deeper understanding.
Great stories rely on the sum of their parts—and so do contracts. Isolating a single sentence or clause to interpret a contract, such as determining whether a party has the ability to terminate for convenience or assessing risks based on one provision alone, can lead to oversimplified assumptions or misinterpretations. Contracts depend on the interplay of their parts to form a comprehensive framework.
Sections within a contract often depend on each other for full meaning:
- A limitation of liability clause might appear to cap damages, but other sections may carve out exceptions, potentially exposing unexpected risks.
- A warranty clause might promise certain standards, but a separate disclaimer could limit liability for failing to meet those standards, creating ambiguity if not read together.
In complex business transactions, multiple contracts often work together to reveal the complete scope of rights and obligations:
- An asset purchase agreement might reference a nondisclosure agreement affecting noncompete terms or intellectual property rights.
- In an equity purchase, a shareholder agreement or the operating agreement may detail additional rights, restrictions, or responsibilities.
Viewing a section or document in isolation risks missing these critical interdependencies—like watching six of eight episodes of a Netflix thriller… and expecting to understand the full plot.
Interpreting a contract requires understanding how all the parts work together to reveal the objectives, risks, rights, and obligations of the parties. Just as a great book like East of Eden deserves to be read in full, so does a well-crafted contract.
Summary
Context Matters: A single sentence in a contract rarely tells the full story—contracts must be taken as a whole.
Sections Work Together: Each part of a contract influences the others, like gears in a machine.
The Whole Picture: Business deals often involve multiple contracts that, together, reveal the full scope and intent of the transaction.
Meet Our Attorney
